The Bills were eliminated after a controversial overtime interception overturned on a disputed catch ruling.

The Buffalo Bills were eliminated from the playoffs after a controversial overtime interception on a deep pass to Brandin Cooks, ruled a legal catch by Broncos defender Ja’Quan McMillian despite appearing to be stripped mid-fall. Officials upheld the call, stating Cooks did not maintain possession before contact, aligning with NFL rules, though no replay challenge was allowed in overtime. Bills coach Sean McDermott criticized the rapid review process, arguing the pivotal play deserved a slower, more deliberate evaluation. The decision sparked widespread debate, with fans and analysts questioning the consistency of catch rulings in high-pressure moments, while the Broncos advanced to the AFC Championship Game.