A Garda superintendent defended using a baton on ex-officer John Bowe during a high-speed chase, calling it justified.

A 6'8" Garda Superintendent testified in Ireland's High Court that his use of a baton to strike former officer John Bowe during a 25-minute, high-speed chase in December 2014 was proportionate and justified. The pursuit, which reached 140 km/h and involved public fear and a Garda vehicle going into a ditch, followed Bowe fleeing a checkpoint due to an unregistered car and alcohol consumption. Sheriff, then a sergeant, said he struck Bowe on the head after believing he was lunging with a knife, though the object was later identified as keys with bottle openers. Bowe, who was convicted of dangerous driving, claims the strike caused a functional neurological disorder, while Sheriff maintained the action was necessary, lawful, and that Bowe remained conscious and cooperative. The case, involving claims against the Garda and state, is ongoing with closing arguments pending.