A non-biological father seeks visitation with children born via surrogacy, claiming co-parenting, against the biological father’s opposition.

An estranged gay couple are in a Family Law Court battle over visitation rights to two young children born via surrogacy overseas. The non-biological father, named on baptismal certificates but not birth records, seeks 10 annual visits, claiming he acted as a co-parent, sharing caregiving duties and forming a strong emotional bond, with the children calling him “Daddy.” He took parental leave and traveled abroad during the pregnancies. The biological father opposes access, arguing the man was only a partner, the children do not recognize him, and they are thriving with stable caregivers. The court reviewed home videos showing family closeness, and the judge noted the family appeared happy. The case hinges on whether the applicant’s role and relationship justify visitation in the children’s best interests.